Justia Arbitration & Mediation Opinion Summaries
Articles Posted in Labor & Employment Law
City of Phila. v. FOP, Lodge No. 5
A police lieutenant in a city police department sent a series of inappropriate and sexual text messages, including a video depicting bestiality, to two female subordinate officers. After an anonymous letter revealed these acts, the department’s Internal Affairs Bureau investigated and the lieutenant was charged with multiple violations of the department’s disciplinary code, including sexual harassment and failure to supervise. The Police Commissioner ordered his dismissal, but the lieutenant, through the union, challenged this action under the collective bargaining agreement, leading to grievance arbitration.At arbitration, the arbitrator found insufficient evidence to support the sexual harassment charge but determined that the lieutenant had violated other sections of the disciplinary code. The arbitrator imposed a fifty-day suspension and ordered the lieutenant’s reinstatement with back pay, concluding that the city lacked just cause for discharge. The city sought to vacate the award in the Court of Common Pleas of Philadelphia County, arguing that the arbitrator exceeded his authority and that the standard of judicial review should be broadened. The trial court denied the city’s petition, holding it was bound by the narrow certiorari scope of review, which permits courts to review only issues concerning the arbitrator’s jurisdiction, regularity of proceedings, excess of powers, or constitutional rights. The Commonwealth Court affirmed, reiterating that the narrow certiorari standard applied and declining to modify it.The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, Eastern District, reviewed whether to overturn its prior decisions in Pennsylvania State Police v. Pennsylvania State Troopers’ Ass’n (Betancourt) and Pennsylvania State Police v. Pennsylvania State Troopers’ Ass’n (Smith), which established and declined to expand the narrow certiorari scope of review for grievance arbitration awards under the Policemen and Firemen Collective Bargaining Act (Act 111). The court held that stare decisis required adherence to these precedents, reaffirming that judicial review of Act 111 grievance arbitration awards remains limited to narrow certiorari, and declined to create a public policy exception or adopt broader review standards. The judgment of the Commonwealth Court was affirmed. View "City of Phila. v. FOP, Lodge No. 5" on Justia Law
O’Malley v. Laborers’ Internatl. Union of N. Am., Local 860
This case involves a dispute between a county juvenile court and a labor union regarding the interpretation and application of two collective-bargaining agreements covering employees at a juvenile detention center and other court employees. Both agreements contained duration clauses, evergreen clauses, and arbitration provisions. When negotiations for successor agreements failed, the juvenile court declared the agreements expired and ceased recognizing the union. In response, the union filed a grievance and counterclaims, asserting that the evergreen clauses extended the agreements until certain conditions were met and that the court breached the agreements by unilaterally terminating them.Initially, the Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas found the agreements were not void ab initio for lack of consideration and recognized an extension of the agreements under the evergreen clauses, but not beyond December 31, 2020, due to public policy. The court ruled the union was entitled to damages for the breach but held that the union’s emailed grievance was not arbitrable, as considering it a grievance would violate public policy. The parties then cross-appealed.The Eighth District Court of Appeals reversed the trial court, holding that disputes concerning the interpretation of the evergreen and duration clauses, as well as the question of when the agreements expired, were subject to arbitration under the agreements. The appellate court ordered the parties to proceed to arbitration.The Supreme Court of Ohio affirmed the Eighth District’s decision. The court held that disputes about the expiration and interpretation of the collective-bargaining agreements are arbitrable, as they concern contract interpretation within the scope of the arbitration clauses. The court found sufficient consideration for the arbitration provisions and determined that challenges to the agreements’ formation did not affect the enforceability of the arbitration clauses. The matter was remanded to the trial court to order arbitration. View "O'Malley v. Laborers' Internatl. Union of N. Am., Local 860" on Justia Law
Castillo v. Belkorp AG, LLP
An employee who worked for a company from May 2021 until his termination in January 2024 signed an arbitration agreement at the start of his employment. This agreement required any employment-related disputes to be resolved through binding arbitration on an individual basis, with a waiver of class and collective actions. In November 2024, the employee notified the Labor and Workforce Development Agency (LWDA) of alleged Labor Code violations by his employer. After the LWDA did not respond within the statutory period, he became authorized to pursue a civil action for penalties under the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA), acting as a proxy for the state. He subsequently filed a complaint in Stanislaus County Superior Court asserting only nonindividual PAGA claims—claims on behalf of other aggrieved employees and not for his own individual recovery—for various Labor Code violations.The employer responded by filing a motion to compel arbitration, arguing that PAGA required the inclusion of individual claims and that the arbitration agreement should apply. The Superior Court denied this motion, noting procedural irregularities and emphasizing that binding precedent allowed PAGA actions consisting solely of nonindividual claims. The court referenced a split in authority on whether PAGA actions could be limited to nonindividual claims, but ultimately relied on decisions holding such actions permissible, especially after recent statutory amendments.On appeal, the California Court of Appeal, Fifth Appellate District, affirmed the trial court’s decision. The appellate court held that, under the version of PAGA effective July 1, 2024, an aggrieved employee may bring a PAGA action consisting only of nonindividual claims and that these claims are not subject to arbitration, even if an arbitration agreement exists. The court further found that the statutory amendments did not require an employee to include individual claims, and that denying arbitration of nonindividual PAGA claims does not violate federal or state policy favoring arbitration. The denial of the motion to compel arbitration was affirmed. View "Castillo v. Belkorp AG, LLP" on Justia Law
Molina v. Triumph Residential Services, Inc.
A property management company in Los Angeles employed an individual from April 2023 to September 2024. As part of the hiring and onboarding process, the employee was required to sign an arbitration agreement that mandated all employment-related claims be resolved through binding arbitration and included a waiver of class and representative actions. The employee later filed a class action lawsuit against the employer, alleging wage-and-hour violations and unfair business practices.The employer responded by filing a motion in the Superior Court of Los Angeles County to compel arbitration of the employee's individual claims, dismiss the class claims, and stay the action. The employer made clear that the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) did not apply and relied on California law. The employee opposed, arguing that under California Labor Code section 432.6, it is illegal for an employer to require an employee to sign an arbitration agreement as a condition of employment unless the agreement is enforceable under the FAA. The Superior Court denied the employer’s motion, finding that the arbitration agreement was required as a condition of employment, thus violating section 432.6, and that, since the FAA did not apply, the agreement was unenforceable under California law.On appeal, the Court of Appeal of the State of California, Second Appellate District, Division Four, affirmed the trial court’s order. The appellate court held that, under California law, an arbitration agreement required as a condition of employment in violation of section 432.6 is unenforceable unless it is otherwise enforceable under the FAA. Because the parties agreed the FAA did not apply and the agreement was required as a condition of employment, the employer could not enforce it. The court affirmed the denial of the motion to compel arbitration. View "Molina v. Triumph Residential Services, Inc." on Justia Law
Diaz-Roa v. Hermes Law
The plaintiff in this case began working for a law firm in 2017 and, in February 2018, signed an arbitration agreement covering most employment-related disputes. Over several years, she rose through the ranks and contributed to the creation of a legal tech company, earning a substantial award of stock options. By August 2023, those options had fully vested, and she communicated her intention to exercise them. Shortly thereafter, in February 2024, she was terminated without warning, despite prior positive performance reviews. In addition to her claims regarding unlawful termination and deprivation of stock options, she alleged that she experienced ongoing sexual harassment from her supervisors, including inappropriate comments and conduct.Prior to this case, the defendants filed a declaratory judgment action in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas seeking confirmation of her termination for cause, and later attempted to compel arbitration. That Texas action was stayed after the plaintiff filed suit in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York. Her complaint included claims for sexual harassment under state and city law, as well as non-harassment claims, such as breach of contract and conversion. The defendants moved to compel arbitration, dismiss, or transfer the case. The district court denied the motion to compel arbitration, holding that the Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act (EFAA) allowed the entire lawsuit to proceed in court, not just the sexual harassment claims. Some claims and parties were dismissed for failure to state a claim, but the key harassment and conversion claims remained.The United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit reviewed the district court’s denial of arbitration de novo. It held that, when properly invoked, the EFAA permits a plaintiff to invalidate a predispute arbitration agreement for the entire lawsuit, not only for claims directly relating to sexual harassment or assault. The Second Circuit affirmed the district court’s order and remanded the case for further proceedings. View "Diaz-Roa v. Hermes Law" on Justia Law
President and Fellows of Harvard College v. Harvard Graduate Students Union – UAW, Local 5118
A union representing graduate student workers at a university filed grievances after certain doctoral students working as research assistants in the psychology department were excluded from the weekly lists of union-represented employees. The union asserted that these students, who conducted lab-based research under faculty supervision and received funding, fit the definition of "Research Assistant" under a collective bargaining agreement (CBA) and should be included in the bargaining unit. The university argued that these students were not statutory "employees" under the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) and therefore not eligible for union representation or inclusion in the bargaining unit.The grievances proceeded to arbitration, where the arbitrator found that the psychology doctoral students qualified as "Research Assistants" under the CBA based on its language, the parties’ history, and past practices, regardless of the funding source. The arbitrator ordered the university to include these students in the bargaining unit and provide lost benefits. The university challenged the arbitration award in the United States District Court for the District of Massachusetts, arguing the arbitrator exceeded her authority and violated public policy. The district court denied the university’s motion to vacate and confirmed the arbitration award, granting costs but not attorney’s fees to the union.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit reviewed the district court’s confirmation of the arbitration award de novo. The First Circuit held that the dispute was substantively arbitrable, the arbitrator’s interpretation of the CBA was plausible and drew from its essence, and the award did not violate public policy. The court affirmed the district court’s decision, allowing the arbitration award to stand. View "President and Fellows of Harvard College v. Harvard Graduate Students Union - UAW, Local 5118" on Justia Law
Newton v. LVMH Moet Hennessy Louis Vuitton Inc.
An attorney who began working for a luxury goods company in 2015 alleged that, soon after she was hired, a male colleague subjected her to repeated sexual harassment and, on one occasion, sexual assault. She reported the conduct internally but claimed that company officials failed to respond appropriately and, instead, retaliated against her. Over the years, she experienced alleged ongoing retaliation, including negative performance reviews, exclusion from work opportunities, and other adverse actions. In 2019, she filed a lawsuit in New York State Supreme Court alleging sexual harassment and retaliation under state and city law. The state trial court denied the employer’s request to compel arbitration, but the Appellate Division, First Department reversed and ordered the case to arbitration based on an arbitration agreement the plaintiff had signed before starting her employment.Following her termination in December 2022, the plaintiff filed a new federal lawsuit in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York against her former employer and a supervisor, asserting claims of retaliation in violation of federal, state, and local law. She also sought leave to amend her complaint to consolidate her federal claims with the earlier claims that were pending in arbitration, arguing that the Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act of 2021 (EFAA) rendered the arbitration agreement unenforceable. The district court dismissed her federal retaliation claims under Rule 12(b)(6), finding she had not plausibly alleged protected activity linked to her termination, and denied her motion to amend, concluding the additional claims remained subject to the arbitration agreement.The United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit reviewed the case. The court held that the plaintiff’s initial complaint plausibly alleged retaliation: refusing to meet with her supervisor to discuss settling her discrimination claims pending in arbitration constituted protected activity, and the circumstances of her termination supported an inference of retaliation. However, the court affirmed the denial of leave to amend, explaining that the additional claims accrued before the EFAA’s effective date and thus remained subject to arbitration. The appellate court affirmed in part, vacated in part, and remanded for further proceedings. View "Newton v. LVMH Moet Hennessy Louis Vuitton Inc." on Justia Law
Joyner v. Frontier Airlines
Three individuals employed as customer service agents for a ground services provider and an airline at Denver International Airport brought a class action lawsuit asserting violations of Colorado’s wage laws. Their complaint alleged that the employers improperly deducted time for lunch breaks not taken, forced work during rest breaks, failed to pay overtime, and withheld commissions. Each employee’s contract contained a mandatory arbitration clause, which the employers sought to enforce under the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) and Colorado law. The employees responded that, as transportation workers, their contracts were exempt from the FAA, and further argued that Colorado law voided such arbitration agreements for wage claims.The United States District Court for the District of Colorado denied the motions to compel arbitration. After an evidentiary hearing, the district court focused narrowly on the specific duties of the three employees, rather than considering the work typically performed by the broader class of customer service agents. It found that the employees “actually and routinely” handled passenger luggage and played a “gatekeeping” role with respect to cargo. On this basis, the court concluded they were transportation workers exempt from the FAA. The district court did not address the request to compel arbitration under Colorado law.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit held that the district court erred by defining the relevant class of workers too narrowly—focusing only on the specific employees, rather than the typical duties of the class as a whole, as required by Supreme Court precedent (including Southwest Airlines Co. v. Saxon). The Tenth Circuit reversed the district court’s order denying the motions to compel arbitration and remanded for further proceedings to properly determine the attributes of the class of workers under the correct legal standard. View "Joyner v. Frontier Airlines" on Justia Law
Mitchell v. Lilac Solutions, Inc.
Four former employees brought claims against their previous employer, a lithium extraction technology company, and several of its managers, alleging wrongful termination, discrimination, exposure to harmful chemicals, and sexual harassment. Each employee had signed an agreement to arbitrate disputes arising out of employment. Despite this, after the lawsuit was filed, the defendants engaged in extensive litigation activity: they filed answers and cross-complaints asserting arbitration rights, initiated and responded to significant discovery, and made multiple procedural motions. Notably, they did not immediately move to compel arbitration, instead doing so only after the plaintiffs filed an anti-SLAPP motion.The Superior Court of California, County of Alameda, denied the defendants’ motion to compel arbitration, finding that the defendants had waived their right to arbitrate by substantially invoking the litigation process and taking steps inconsistent with an intent to arbitrate. The court relied on factors from prior California appellate decisions, focusing on the defendants’ conduct in court and their use of discovery tools not typically available in arbitration. The court did not find it necessary to decide whether the Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act (EFAA) applied, as its waiver finding was dispositive.On appeal, the Court of Appeal of the State of California, First Appellate District, Division Four, affirmed the trial court’s order. The appellate court held that the trial court’s waiver analysis was consistent with the California Supreme Court’s decision in Quach v. California Commerce Club, Inc., which clarified that waiver of the right to arbitrate focuses solely on the party’s conduct and intent, not on prejudice to the opposing party. The appellate court found substantial evidence that the defendants intentionally relinquished their arbitration rights by actively litigating in court prior to seeking arbitration, and thus affirmed the denial of the motion to compel arbitration. View "Mitchell v. Lilac Solutions, Inc." on Justia Law
DING V. STRUCTURE THERAPEUTICS, INC.
A former Chief Financial Officer of a clinical drug development company was terminated shortly after experiencing a domestic violence incident and requesting limited accommodations at work. She alleged that her supervisor sidelined her, assigned her diminished responsibilities, and ultimately terminated her for reasons related to her gender and experience as a domestic violence victim. After her termination, she initially filed an arbitration demand asserting discrimination and harassment based on national origin and her status as a domestic violence victim. During discovery in the arbitration process, she uncovered evidence suggesting her mistreatment was motivated by sex. She then withdrew from arbitration and filed suit in state court, asserting sex discrimination and hostile work environment claims.The employer removed the case to the United States District Court for the Northern District of California and moved to compel arbitration, arguing that the Federal Arbitration Act and related federal law preempted any state procedural rules allowing withdrawal from arbitration. The district court ruled that, although state procedural rules were preempted, the Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act of 2021 (EFAA) gave the plaintiff the right to invalidate the arbitration agreement and proceed in court based on plausible allegations of sexual harassment. The district court found that the plaintiff did not know of her sexual harassment claim when she initiated arbitration and had not waived her rights under the EFAA.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed the district court’s order denying the motion to compel arbitration. The court held that the EFAA allows plaintiffs to elect to proceed in court once they discover a sexual harassment claim, even if they initially pursued other claims in arbitration, so long as they did not intentionally relinquish a known right. The court further found the plaintiff plausibly alleged a sex-based hostile work environment claim under California law and thus under the EFAA. View "DING V. STRUCTURE THERAPEUTICS, INC." on Justia Law